Should AI answer questions or search first?

Search first, then decide. Classify the intent before choosing a response format: return results for discovery and comparison, generate an answer for single-fact questions, show a form or account data for transactions, and escalate to a human when confidence is low. Answering everything in prose is the common failure.

A routing table

IntentExampleRight response
Discoveryblack dress for a partyResults grid
Known itemsilk kurta 42Direct result
Comparisonwool vs cashmereComparison view
Factwhat is the return windowGenerated answer with source
Transactionwhere is order 4521Account data, not prose
Supportthis arrived damagedHuman handoff

Why prose-first fails

Describing six jackets in a paragraph is strictly worse than showing six jackets. Visitors comparing options need parallel presentation — image, price, availability — and prose destroys it. The interface should match the shape of the task, not the shape of the technology.

Always show the source

When the system does generate an answer, link the page it came from. It lets the visitor verify, it protects trust when the model is wrong, and it turns the answer into a route into the site rather than a terminus.